Sanders, J, McLeod, H, Small, A & Strachotta, C 2019, 'Mine closure residual risk management: identifying and managing credible failure modes for tailings and mine waste', in AB Fourie & M Tibbett (eds), Mine Closure 2019: Proceedings of the 13th International Conference on Mine Closure
, Australian Centre for Geomechanics, Perth, pp. 535-552, https://doi.org/10.36487/ACG_rep/1915_44_Sanders
Closure planning relies on a solid understanding of risk management. With tailings and other mine waste facilities representing a significant life-of-mine (LoM) liability associated with the mining industry, a proper understanding and management of residual risk at closure is fundamental to implementing a mine closure plan that will be considered successful. Having a comprehensive technical basis of the triggering events and credible failure modes after closure that may impact receptors and prohibit meeting closure objectives is crucial. Performance evaluation and success criteria can then be properly developed and assessed against closure objectives and obligations.
In the wake of the recent Mount Polley, Fundão and Brumadinho mine tailings disasters, we are reminded that decisions made, past and present, affect the social acceptability of the industry in the future. The physical stability mechanisms that caused these tailings dam failures to occur can be present throughout the LoM into post-closure and represent an unacceptable long-term risk to society and the mine owner. Existing and closed facilities will still require post-closure stewardship to ensure protection of life, property and the environment regardless of future improved tailings technologies for new projects.
Risk assessment can be a valuable tool for providing insight to the safety of a tailings facility and educating the mine closure planning team. Risk assessments should be conducted at each phase of a mine life, from design to closure, and are often undertaken. However, the authors of this paper have identified several challenges with risk assessments and, in this paper, have provided several recommendations to improve risk assessments for dam safety. We have built upon the guidance provided by ISO 3100:2018 on risk management. With this foundation established, the paper then discusses some of the unique challenges and relevant case studies associated with risk assessments for closure residual risk. If the risk assessments conducted during design and operation are flawed, then the risk assessment for the closure residual risk will have reduced value.
Keywords: mine closure, post-closure residual risk, credible failure modes, tailings and mine waste
Ministry of Energy, Mines, and Petroleum Resources 2017, Health, Safety and Reclamation Code for Mines in British Columbia, Crown Publications, Victoria.
Bowben, AR, Lane, MR & Martin, JH 2001, Triple Bottom Line Risk Management - Enhancing Profit, Environmental Performance and Community Benefits, Wiley.
Canadian Dam Association 2014, Application of Dam Safety Guidelines to Mining Dams, Toronto.
Ernst and Young 2019, Business Risks Facing Mining and Metals: 2019 – 2020, London.
Dekker, S 2018, Drift into Failure, Routledge, Abingdon.
Government of Saskatchewan 2018, Institutional Control Monitoring and Maintenance Fund and the Unforeseen Events Fund Annual Report 2017-18, Ministry of Economy, Regina.
Hopkins, A 2008, Failure to Learn: the BP Texas City Refinery Disaster, CCH Australia, Sydney.
International Council on Mining and Metals 2019, Integrated Mine Closure Good Practice Guide, London.
International Council on Mining and Metals 2015, Health and Safety Critical Control Management, London.
International Organization for Standardization 2018, Risk Management – Guidelines (31000:2018), Geneva.
Lo, RC, Stroiazzo, J & Guilleminot, G 2009, ‘Transition of a major tailings facility in a sensitive environment — from operation to decommissioning at Brenda Mine’, in AB Fourie & M Tibbett (eds), Proceedings of the Fourth International Conference on Mine Closure, Australian Centre for Geomechanics, Perth, pp. 229–243.
MBS Geoconsulting 2016, 2016 DSI report for the Brenda Mine Site, viewed 10 May 10 2019,
Morgenstern, N 2018, ‘The 6th Victor de Mello Lecture: geotechnical risk, regulation and public policy’, paper presented at the 9th Portugse–Brazillian Geotechnical Congress, Salvador, 30 August 2018.
Newmont 2014, News Release: Indigenous Consulting Group to Help Clear Pathway to Hand Over Woodcutters, viewed 24 July 2019,
Oil Sands Tailings Dam Committee 2014, De-licensing of Oil Sands Tailings Dams. Technical Guidance Document,
Queensland Resource Council 2019, Managing Residual Risk in Queensland, Queensland Government.
Rynhoud, MS, Johns, D & Murray, L 2017, ‘The Hamata Tailings Dam design and construction at the Hidden Valley Mine in Papua New Guinea’, presented at the ANCOLD 2017 Conference, Hobart, 26–27 October 2017.
Sanders, J Wendtman, M & Sexton, A 2018, ‘Change management over the life of mine: challenges and opportunities for closure residual risks’, in C Drebenstedt, F von Bismarck, AB Fourie & M Tibbett (eds), Proceedings of the 12th International Conference on Mine Closure, Technical University Bergakademie Freiberg, Freiberg, pp. 315–329.
Sanders, J & Wendtman, M 2016, ‘Managing knowledge loss over the life of mine: opportunities and challenges’, Proceedings of Risk and Resilience Mining Solutions 2016, InfoMine Inc., Vancouver.
Swart, P & Erskine, PD 2018, ‘Residual risk policy and processes – what is holding the industry back from achieving mine closure ad lease relinquishment’, in C Drebenstedt, F von Bismarck, AB Fourie & M Tibbett (eds), Proceedings of the 12th International Conference on Mine Closure, Technical University Bergakademie Freiberg, Freiberg, pp. 189–197.
Bureau of Reclamation 2015, Best Practice in Dam and Levee Safety Risk Analysis, viewed September 2018,
Vick, S 2007, ‘Dams, levees, and risk – the good, the bad, and the ugly’, Proceedings of 26th Annual Water Management Conference, American Society of Civil Engineers, Reston.
Vick, S 2017, ‘From deviance to diligence’, in J Huang, GA Fenton, L Zhang & DV Griffiths (eds), Proceedings of Geo-Risk 2017, American Society of Civil Engineers, Reston.