Daws, MI, Grigg, AH, Blackburn, C, Barker, JM, Standish, RJ & Tibbett, M 2022, 'Initial conditions can have long-term effects on plant species diversity in jarrah forest restored after bauxite mining', in AB Fourie, M Tibbett & G Boggs (eds), Mine Closure 2022: 15th International Conference on Mine Closure
, Australian Centre for Geomechanics, Perth, pp. 857-868, https://doi.org/10.36487/ACG_repo/2215_62
Much of the remarkable plant species diversity of the Southwest Australian Floristic Region can be attributed to high diversity of the understorey in its forests and woodlands, including 400–600 understorey species per km2 in the Northern Jarrah Forest alone. Consequently, returning species diversity is a key challenge for postmining ecological restoration in the region. Each year, Alcoa of Australia undertakes restoration of mined areas within the Northern Jarrah Forest with a goal of returning a self-sustaining jarrah forest ecosystem. To meet this goal, it is important to understand long-term (i.e. > 20 years) trajectories of vegetation development and the restoration practices that direct species diversity outcomes. Here, we report the results of several experiments, the oldest of which is 45 years of age, which together demonstrate significant longer-term effects on understorey species diversity of restoration practices determining initial conditions including topsoil handling, fertiliser application, seeding rates of large legumes, and tree (overstorey) species stocking rates. Our research highlights (1) that ‘historical contingency’ can determine the trajectory of jarrah forest restoration and (2) that longer-term studies are critical as they give a different, sometimes conflicting, perspective to short-term datasets. Notably, after 27 years, we found an inverse relationship between plant cover and P fertilisation, where plant cover was highest in the in the absence of P fertiliser and lowest at the uppermost P amendment rate. We also found that the long-accepted Initial Floristics Model of succession does not fit well with our data. Our overall findings are likely useful to restore understorey diversity to woodlands, forests, and abandoned farmlands elsewhere in the region.
Keywords: fertiliser, legumes, phosphorus, productivity, topsoil, species richness, tree stocking
Australian Bureau of Meteorology 2015, Monthly Climate Statistics for Dwellingup, Melbourne, viewed November 2015,
Bell, IC 2001, ‘Establishment of native ecosystems after mining - Australian experience across diverse biogeographic zones’, Ecological Engineering, vol. 17, pp. 179–186.
Chan, SS, Larson, DJ, Maas-Hebner, KG, Emmingham, WH, Johnston, SR & Mikowski, DA 2006, ‘Overstory and understory development in thinned and underplanted Oregon Coast Range Douglas-fir stands’, Canadian Journal of Forest Research, vol. 36, pp. 2696–2711.
Daws, MI, Ballard, C, Mullins, CE, Garwood, NC, Murray, B, Pearson, TRH & Burslem, DFRP 2007, ‘Allometric relationships between seed mass and seedling characteristics reveal trade-offs for neotropical gap-dependent species’, Oecologia, vol. 54,
Daws, MI, Grigg, AH, Tibbett, M & Standish, RJ 2019, ‘Enduring effects of large legumes and phosphorus fertiliser on jarrah forest restoration 15 years after bauxite mining’, Forest Ecology and Management, vol. 438, pp. 204–214.
Daws, MI & Koch, JM 2015, ‘Long-term restoration success of re-sprouter understorey species is facilitated by protection from herbivory and a reduction in competition’, Plant Ecology, vol. 216, pp. 565–576.
Daws, MI, Standish, RJ, Koch, JM & Morald, TK 2013, ‘Nitrogen and phosphorus fertiliser regime affect jarrah forest restoration after bauxite mining in Western Australia’, Applied Vegetation Science, vol. 16, pp. 610–618.
Daws, MI, Standish, RJ, Koch, JM, Morald, TK, Tibbett, M & Hobbs, RJ 2015, ‘Phosphorus fertilisation and large legume species affect jarrah forest restoration after bauxite mining’, Forest Ecology and Management, vol. 354, pp. 10–17.
Daws, MI, Walters, SJ, Harris, RJ, Tibbett, M, Grigg, AH, Morald, TK, Hobbs, RJ & Standish, RJ 2021, ‘Nutrient enrichment diminishes plant diversity and density, and alters long-term ecological trajectories, in a biodiverse forest restoration’, Ecological Engineering, vol. 165, 106222.
de Campos, MCR, Pearse, SJ, Oliveira, RS & Lambers, H 2013, ‘Downregulation of net phosphorus-uptake capacity is inversely related to leaf phosphorus-resorption proficiency in four species from a phosphorus-impoverished environment’, Annals of Botany, vol. 111, pp. 445–454.
DFAT 2016, Mine Rehabilitation: Leading Practice Sustainable Development Program for the Mining Industry, Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Commonwealth Government of Australia, Canberra.
Egler, FE 1954, ‘Vegetation science concepts. I. Initial floristic composition, a factor in oldfield vegetation development’, Vegetatio, vol. 4, pp. 412–417.
Environment Protection Agency 1995, ‘Rehabilitation and revegetation’, Best Practice Environmental Management in Mining, Commonwealth of Australia, Canberra.
Fukami, T 2015, ‘Historical contingency in community assembly: integrating niches, species pools, and priority effects’, Annual Review of Ecology, Evolution, and Systematics, vol. 46, pp. 1–23.
Gardner, JH & Bell, DT 2007, ‘Bauxite mining restoration by Alcoa World Alumina Australia in Western Australia: social, political, historical, and environmental contexts’, Restoration Ecology, vol. 15, pp. S3–S10.
Golos, PJ & Dixon, KW 2014, ‘Waterproofing topsoil stockpiles minimizes viability decline in the soil seed bank in an arid environment’, Restoration Ecology, vol. 22, pp. 495–501.
Golos, PJ, Dixon, KW & Erickson, TE 2016, ‘Plant recruitment from the soil seed bank depends on topsoil stockpile age, height, and storage history in an arid environment’, Restoration Ecology, vol. 24, pp. S53–S61.
Grant, CD, Ward, SC & Morley, SC 2007, ‘Return of ecosystem function to restored bauxite mines in Western Australia’, Restoration Ecology, vol. 15, pp. S94–S103.
Grigg, A 2012, ‘Adaptive rehabilitation management and a drying climate: unique challenges for Alcoa's bauxite mine rehabilitation in southwestern Australia’, Mine Closure 2012 - A.B. Fourie and M. Tibbett (eds), Australian Centre for Geomechanics, Perth.
Grigg, AH, MacFarlane, C, Evangelista, C, Eamus, D & Adams, MA 2008, ‘Does initial spacing influence crown and hydraulic architecture of Eucalyptus marginata?’, Tree Physiology, vol. 28, pp. 753–760.
Holl, KD 2002, ‘Long-term vegetation recovery on reclaimed coal surface mines in the eastern USA’, Journal of Applied Ecology, vol. 39, pp. 960–970.
Koch, JM 1987, ‘Nitrogen accumulation in a rehabilitated bauxite-mined area in the Darling Range, Western Australia’, Australian Forestry Research, vol. 17, pp. 59–72.
Koch, JM & Ward, SC 2005, ‘Thirteen-year growth of jarrah (Eucalyptus marginata) on rehabilitated bauxite mines in south-western Australia’, Australian Forestry, vol. 68, pp. 176–185.
Koch, JM, Ward, SC, Grant, CD & Ainsworth, GL 1996, ‘Effects of bauxite mine restoration operations on topsoil seed reserves in the jarrah forest of Western Australia’, Restoration Ecology, vol. 4, pp. 368–376.
Norman, MA, Koch, JM, Grant, CD, Morald, TK & Ward, SC 2006, ‘Vegetation succession after bauxite mining in Western Australia’, Restoration Ecology, vol. 14, pp. 278–288.
Shane, MW, McCully, ME & Lambers, H 2004b, ‘Tissue and cellular phosphorus storage during development of phosphorus toxicity in Hakea prostrata (Proteaceae)’, Journal of Experimental Botany, 55, pp. 1033–1044.
Shane, MW, Szota, C & Lambers, H 2004a, ‘A root trait accounting for the extreme phosphorus sensitivity of Hakea prostrata (Proteaceae)’, Plant Cell and Environment, vol. 27, pp. 991–1004.
Standish, RJ, Daws, MI, Gove AD, Didham, RK, Grigg, AH, Koch, JM & Hobbs, RJ 2015, ‘Long-term data suggest jarrah-forest establishment at restored mine sites is resistant to climate variability’, Journal of Ecology, vol. 103, pp. 78–89.
Standish, R.J, Daws, MI, Morald, TK, Speijers, J, Koch, JM, Hobbs, RJ & Tibbett, M 2022, ‘Phosphorus supply affects seedling growth of mycorrhizal but not cluster-root forming jarrah-forest species’, Plant and Soil, vol. 472, pp. 577–594.
Standish, RJ, Gove, AD, Grigg, AH & Daws, MI 2021, ‘Beyond species richness and community composition: using plant functional diversity to measure restoration success in jarrah forest’, Applied Vegetation Science, vol. 24, e12607.
Tacey, WH & Glossop, BL 1980, ‘Assessment of topsoil handling techniques for rehabilitation of sites mined for bauxite within the jarrah forest of Western Australia’, Journal of Applied Ecology, vol. 17, pp. 195–201.
Tibbett, M 2010, ‘Large-scale mine site restoration of Australian eucalypt forests after bauxite mining: soil management and ecosystem development’, in LC Batty & K Hallberg (eds), Ecology of Industrial Pollution, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 309–326.
Tibbett, M, Daws, MI, George, SJ & Ryan, MH 2020, ‘The where, when and what of phosphorus fertilisation for seedling establishment in a biodiverse jarrah forest restoration after bauxite mining in Western Australia’, Ecological Engineering, vol. 153, 105907.
Tibbett, M, Daws, MI & Ryan, MH 2022, ‘Phosphorus uptake and toxicity is delimited by mycorrhizal symbiosis in P-sensitive Eucalyptus marginata but not in P-tolerant Acacia celastrifolia’, AoB Plants, plac037.
Ward, SC & Koch, JM 1995, ‘Early growth of jarrah (Eucalyptus marginata Donn ex Smith) on rehabilitated bauxite minesites in southwest Australia’, Australian Forestry, vol. 58, pp. 65–71.
Ward, SC, & Koch, JM 1996, ‘Biomass and nutrient distribution in a 15.5 year old forest growing on a rehabilitated bauxite mine’, Australian Journal of Ecology, vol. 21, pp. 309–315.
Ward, SC, Koch, JM & Nichols, OG 1990, ‘Bauxite mine rehabilitation in the Darling Range, Western Australia’, Proceedings of the Ecological Society of Australia, vol. 16, pp. 557–565.
Waryszak, P, Standish, RJ, Ladd, PG, Enright, NJ, Brundrett, M & Fontaine, JB 2021, ’Best served deep: the seedbank from salvaged topsoil underscores the role of the dispersal filter in restoration practice’, Applied Vegetation Science, vol. 24, e12539.
Williams, A, George, S, Birt, HWG, Daws, MI & Tibbett, M 2019, ‘Sensitivity of seedling growth to phosphorus supply in six tree species of the Australian Great Western Woodlands’, Australian Journal of Botany, vol. 67, pp. 390–396.
Wilson, JB, Gitay, H, Roxburgh, SH, King, WM & Tangney, RS 1992, ‘Egler’s concept of 'Initial Floristic Composition' in succession: ecologists citing it don't agree what it means’, Oikos, vol. 64, pp. 591–593.
Young, TP, Petersen, DA & Clary, JJ 2005, ‘The ecology of restoration: historical links, emerging issues and unexplored realms’, Ecology Letters, vol. 8, pp. 662–673.
Zangy, E, Kigel, J, Cohen, S, Moshe, Y, Ashkenazi, M, Fragman-Sapir, O & Osem, Y 2021, ‘Understory plant diversity under variable overstory cover in Mediterranean forests at different spatial scales’, Forest Ecology and Management, vol. 494, 119319.