DOI https://doi.org/10.36487/ACG_repo/2415_15
Cite As:
Wilson-Clark, C, Macmillan, G, Winn, R & Martinez, C 2024, 'The power of collaboration and realism in social transition planning: an improved foundation for success in remote Australia', in AB Fourie, M Tibbett & G Boggs (eds),
Mine Closure 2024: Proceedings of the 17th International Conference on Mine Closure, Australian Centre for Geomechanics, Perth, pp. 231-244,
https://doi.org/10.36487/ACG_repo/2415_15
Abstract:
Social transition planning has traditionally been led by the operator as the party responsible for closing the asset and minimising negative impacts for communities and other stakeholders. In this paper, WSP and Rio Tinto’s cross-disciplinary social and economic specialists argue for the benefits of social transition planning as a joint responsibility of a multi-stakeholder group, comprising key organisations and governments, who maintain a community presence post-closure, in close partnership with the closing operation. We suggest high order priority should be given to First Nations peoples as landowners, social and economic leaders, and custodians of culture and country.
To support this approach, input on detailed data-driven studies (in the tradition of robust socio-economic impact assessments) that predicts and discloses the reality of the post-closure scenario should be obtained and analysed with the multi-stakeholder group governing the study. The paper draws on recent experience delivering such a study at the Rio Tinto-operated Gove bauxite mine in the Australian Northern Territory, on the Gove Peninsula in East Arnhem Land. Here, Traditional Owners and their organisations contribute to and drive outcomes through their membership and active contribution to the Gove Peninsula Futures Reference Group (GPFRG). The group has articulated a clear post-mining vision for Nhulunbuy and the Gove Peninsula. Group members have worked with the study team to interrogate data, share and test potential investment options, and adapt approaches and planning scenarios to progress towards improved outcomes.
This highly collaborative model requires sophisticated engagement skills and a degree of compromise or ‘letting go’ on the part of the operator, which can challenge typical approaches. We suggest the model can be implemented in a way which supports operators who are genuinely interested in leaving communities with positive legacies focused on a successful and sustainable alternative future.
The authors would like to express their acknowledgement of and deep respect for the Traditional Owners and Custodians of the land, sea and waters of the Gove Peninsula in East Arnhem Land, the Yolŋu. It is with the Yolŋu vision for a vibrant and self-determined future that this paper is delivered.
Keywords: social transition, mine closure, socio-economic impact assessment, stakeholder partnerships, collaborative engagement, communities, economic modelling, post-closure vision, First Nations peoples, Aboriginal Traditional Owners
References:
GPFRG 2021, A New Journey Together – Traditional Owners’ Vision for the Future of Nhulunbuy and the Gove Peninsula, viewed 13 May 2024,
Gumatj Corporation and Rirratjingu Aboriginal Corporation 2022, Yolŋu Social Impact Study – Joint Study of the Social Impacts of Rio Tinto Mining Closure for Yolŋu, Phase 1: Draft Findings Report, unpublished.
OECD 2020a, Linking Indigenous Communities with Regional Development in Australia, viewed 13 May 2024.
OECD 2020b, Linking Indigenous Communities with Regional Development in Canada, viewed 13 May 2024.
Office of Northern Australia 2023, Regions of Growth International Comparison of Regional Growth Approaches, Canberra, unpublished.
Regional Development Australia NT 2024, RDA Northern Territory: About the Profile Areas, viewed 9 August 2024,
Rio Tinto 2021, Closure Standard, CLO-B-001, approved May 2021, effective July 2021, corporate standard, unpublished.
Rio Tinto 2022, Communities and Social Performance Standard, viewed 16 October 2024,
sustainability/policies
Tomaney, J 2010, Place-based Approaches to Regional Development: Global Trends and Australian Implications, report for the Australian Business Foundation,
Place_based_competitiveness_australia.pdf
Vodden, K, Douglas, DJA, Markey, S, Minnes, S & Reimer, B (eds) 2019, The Theory, Practice, and Potential of Regional Development the Case of Canada, Routledge, New York.
WSP 2024, Gove Mine Closure Socio-Economic Impact Assessment, viewed 13 May 2024,
Yothu Yindi Foundation 2022, Our Custodians, viewed March 2024,
, no longer published.
Yothu Yindi Foundation 2024, What We Do: The Garma Festival, viewed 9 August 2024,