DOI https://doi.org/10.36487/ACG_repo/2615_37
Cite As:
Hesketh, P 2026, 'Determining the vulnerability of asset retirement obligations across the mining sector', in AB Fourie, G Boggs, J Heyes & M Tibbett (eds),
Mine Closure 2026: Proceedings of the 19th International Conference on Mine Closure, Australian Centre for Geomechanics, Perth, pp. 1-10,
https://doi.org/10.36487/ACG_repo/2615_37
Abstract:
Asset retirement obligations (AROs) detail the corporate liability associated with decommissioning and environmental rehabilitation across a corporate portfolio, i.e. they represent the committed cost of closure across the whole company. An ARO is effectively a debt on a company’s balance sheet as the accounting treatment provides a single aggregated number that is discounted for future spend. AROs are opaque, and it is difficult for investors to understand the potential impact of cost increases and non-discretionary annual spending commitments, and consequently the risks that sit within investment portfolios. AROs for major mining organisations have increased substantially, with 11 miners reporting a combined USD 36.2 billion increase between 2015 and 2024, amounting to an 8% year-on-year increase despite individual annual spend of up to USD 1.1 billion (Rio Tinto 2024).
The long-term nature of AROs, with a cost horizon typically exceeding 15 years at the corporate level, places them outside the interest of ratings agencies, which are more concerned with risks within a shorter time frame (<5 years).
ARO vulnerability assesses the potential for cost escalation at the portfolio level. The assessment involves unravelling the ARO to determine the probable total cost of closure at a corporate level and then an assessment of causative factors within the portfolios which would be likely to increase closure costs over the life of the assets within the portfolio. It provides a tool to address corporate closure performance by heightening investor knowledge, enabling modelling of closure impacts on investor portfolios and feeding into a closure/transition mark.
References:
AACE 2022, PGD 01 - Guide to Cost Estimate Classification Professional Guidance Document No. 01 - Guide to Cost Estimate Classification Systems.
Alcoa 2016, Annual Report 2015,
Alcoa 2017, Annual Report 2016,
Alcoa 2018, Annual Report 2017,
Alcoa 2019, Annual Report 2018,
Alcoa 2020, Annual Report 2019,
Alcoa 2021, Annual Report 2020,
Alcoa 2022, Annual Report 2021,
Alcoa 2023, Annual Report 2022,
Alcoa 2024, Annual Report 2023,
Alcoa 2025, Annual Report 2024,
Anglo American 2016, Annual Report 2015,
Anglo American 2017, Annual Report 2016,
Anglo American 2018, Annual Report 2017,
Anglo American 2019, Integrated Annual Report 2018,
Anglo American 2020, Integrated Annual Report 2015,
Anglo American 2021, Integrated Annual Report 2019,
Anglo American 2022, Integrated Annual Report 2021,
Anglo American 2023, Integrated Annual Report 2022,
Anglo American 2024, Integrated Annual Report 2023,
Anglo American 2025, Integrated Annual Report 2024,
Barrick Gold Corporation 2016, Annual Report 2015,
Barrick Gold Corporation 2017, Annual Report 2016,
Barrick Gold Corporation 2018, Annual Report 2017,
Barrick Gold Corporation 2019, Annual Report 2018,
Barrick Gold Corporation 2020, Annual Report 2019,
Barrick Gold Corporation 2021, Annual Report 2020,
Barrick Gold Corporation 2022, Annual Report 2021,
Barrick Gold Corporation 2023, Annual Report 2022,
Barrick Gold Corporation 2024, Annual Report 2023,
Barrick Gold Corporation 2025, Annual Report 2024,
BHP 2016, Annual Report, 2015,
BHP 2017, Annual Report, 2016,
BHP 2018, Annual Report, 2017,
BHP 2019, Annual Report, 2018,
BHP 2020, Annual Report, 2019,
BHP 2021, Annual Report, 2020,
BHP 2022, Annual Report, 2021,
BHP 2023, Annual Report, 2022,
BHP 2024, Annual Report, 2023,
BHP 2025, Annual Report, 2024,
Bloemhof, R Bothma, J 2025, ‘Navigating uncertainty: towards resilient cost estimation in mine closure’, in S Knutsson, AB Fourie & M Tibbett (eds), Mine Closure 2025: Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Mine Closure, Australian Centre for Geomechanics, Perth,
BNP Paribas 2025, The USD 586 Billion Clean-up Bill: How Decommissioning Liabilities Threaten Corporate Balance Sheets.
Botes, A, Sheridan, C & Steyn, C 2025, ‘A probabilistic framework for mine closure financial liability assessment’, in S Knutsson, AB Fourie & M Tibbett (eds), Mine Closure 2025: Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Mine Closure, Australian Centre for Geomechanics, Perth,
Byrne, G, 2013, ‘Long-term water management - the forgotten legacy of mine closure’, Proceedings Water in Mining 2013, Australasian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy, Melbourne.
Carbon Tracker 2025, Asset Retirement Obligations: What Lies Beneath?, Transparency Assessment Report,
Climate Action 100+ 2023, 2023 Proxy Season: Climate Accounting and Asset Retirement Obligations,
Department of Transport and Main Roads 2017, Project Cost Estimating Manual, 7th edn, Queensland Government.
Energy Resources of Australia, ASX Announcement: September 2023 Quarter Operations Review and Business Update, Darwin,
Environmental Resources Management 2023, Optimising Financial and Sustainability Value in Mine Closure,
Ernst & Young 2022, Financial Reporting Developments: Asset Retirement Obligations.
Financial Accounting Standards Board 2024, Accounting Standards Codification (ASC) 410: Asset Retirement and Environmental Obligations, Norwalk.
Fitzgerald, D 2022, ‘Ranger uranium mine rehabilitation costs could blow out to $2.2 billion, Energy Resources tells ASX’, ABC News, viewed 2 June 2026,
Freeport-McMoRan 2016, 2015 Annual Report,
Freeport-McMoRan 2017, 2016 Annual Report,
Freeport-McMoRan 2018, 2017 Annual Report,
Freeport-McMoRan 2019, 2018 Annual Report,
Freeport-McMoRan 2020, 2019 Annual Report,
Freeport-McMoRan 2021, 2020 Annual Report,
Freeport-McMoRan 2022, 2021 Annual Report,
Freeport-McMoRan 2023, 2022 Annual Report,
Freeport-McMoRan 2024, 2023 Annual Report,
Freeport-McMoRan 2025, 2024 Annual Report,
Glencore 2016, Annual Report 2015,
Glencore 2017, Annual Report 2016,
Glencore 2018, Annual Report 2017,
Glencore 2019, Annual Report 2018,
Glencore 2020, Annual Report 2019,
Glencore 2021, Annual Report 2020,
Glencore 2022, Annual Report 2021,
Glencore 2023, Annual Report 2022,
Glencore 2024, Annual Report 2023,
Glencore 2025, Annual Report 2024,
Guerra, M, Pedlar, R & Hesketh, P 2025, ‘Building confidence in mine closure cost estimates: a practical approach to risk and uncertainty management’, in S Knutsson, AB Fourie & M Tibbett (eds), Mine Closure 2025: Proceedings of the 18th International Conference on Mine Closure, Australian Centre for Geomechanics, Perth,
ACG_repo/2515_30
Hesketh, P, Tillotson, S & Watts, R 2023, ‘Using uncertainty analysis to unravel cost risks for nuclear and mine site closure’, in B Abbasi, J Parshley, A Fourie & M Tibbett (eds), Mine Closure 2023: Proceedings of the 16th International Conference on Mine Closure, Australian Centre for Geomechanics, Perth,
IFRS Foundation 2026, IAS 37 Provisions, Contingent Liabilities and Contingent Assets.
Infrastructure and Projects Authority, 2021, Cost Estimating Requirements, A Technical Guide for Cost Estimating Teams and Professionals, Government of the United Kingdom.
Investors for Paris Compliance 2026, Kicking the Can Down the Road: Post-AGM Analysis of the Oil & Gas Liabilities Gap,
James, F 2018, ‘Ranger Uranium Mine rehabilitation costs blow out by $296m amid fears over long-term monitoring’, ABC News, viewed 2 June 2026,
JORC 2024, Australasian Code for Reporting of Exploration Targets, Exploration Results, Mineral Resources and Ore Reserves, The JORC Code - Guidance Notes, Exposure Draft.
Michelon, G; Paananen, M; Schneider, T, Black Box Accounting: Discounting and disclosure practices of decommissioning liabilities, ICAS 2020
Mining 2030, 2025, Positive Legacies for Mine Closure and Post-Closure Transition.
Moody’s 2024, ‘Reclamation obligations at $78 billion and rising, posing credit risk for miners’, Special Series: ESG – Environmental, Metals & Mining – Global.
Newmont 2016, 2015 Annual Report,
Newmont 2017, 2016 Annual Report,
Newmont 2018, 2017 Annual Report,
Newmont 2019, 2018 Annual Report,
Newmont 2020, 2019 Annual Report,
Newmont 2021, 2020 Annual Report,
Newmont 2022, 2021 Annual Report,
Newmont 2023, 2022 Annual Report,
Newmont 2024, 2023 Annual Report,
Newmont 2025, 2024 Annual Report,
Rio Tinto 2016, 2015 Annual Report,
Rio Tinto 2017, 2016 Annual Report,
Rio Tinto 2018, 2017 Annual Report,
Rio Tinto 2019, 2018 Annual Report,
Rio Tinto 2020, 2019 Annual Report,
Rio Tinto 2021, 2020 Annual Report,
Rio Tinto 2022, 2021 Annual Report,
Rio Tinto 2023, 2022 Annual Report,
Rio Tinto 2024, 2023 Annual Report,
Rio Tinto 2025, 2024 Annual Report,
Risk Engineering Society 2025, Contingency Guideline, 3rd edn, Engineers Australia, Canberra.
Sanders, J, Slingerland, N & Murphy, D 2024, ‘Closing the gap: closure cost estimation trends and pathways to improved maturity’, in AB Fourie, M Tibbett & G Boggs (eds), Mine Closure 2024: Proceedings of the 17th International Conference on Mine Closure, Australian Centre for Geomechanics, Perth, pp. 1149–1162,
South 32 2016, Annual Report 2015,
South 32 2017, Annual Report 2016,
South 32 2018, Annual Report 2017,
South 32 2019, Annual Report 2018,
South 32 2020, Annual Report 2019,
South 32 2021, Annual Report 2020,
South 32 2022, Annual Report 2021,
South 32 2023, Annual Report 2022,
South 32 2024, Annual Report 2023,
South 32 2025, Annual Report 2024,
Teck 2016, 2015 Annual Report,
Teck 2017, 2016 Annual Report,
Teck 2018, 2017 Annual Report,
Teck 2019, 2018 Annual Report,
Teck 2020, 2019 Annual Report,
Teck 2021, 2020 Annual Report,
Teck 2022, 2021 Annual Report,
Teck 2023, 2022 Annual Report,
Teck 2024, 2023 Annual Report,
Teck 2025, 2024 Annual Report,
Turner & Townsend, 2023 “Five steps to improving financial provisions for mine closure.”,
Vale 2016, 2015 Annual Report,
Vale 2017, 2016 Annual Report,
Vale 2018, 2017 Annual Report,
Vale 2019, 2018 Annual Report,
Vale 2020, 2019 Annual Report,
Vale 2021, 2020 Annual Report,
Vale 2022, 2021 Annual Report,
Vale 2023, 2022 Annual Report,
Vale 2024, 2023 Annual Report,
Vale 2025, 2024 Annual Report,