Stoch, EJ, Winde, F & Erasmus, E 2008, 'Karst, Mining and Conflict — A Historical Perspective of the Consequences of Mining on the Far West Rand', in AB Fourie, M Tibbett, I Weiersbye & P Dye (eds), Mine Closure 2008: Proceedings of the Third International Seminar on Mine Closure
, Australian Centre for Geomechanics, Perth, pp. 69-83, https://doi.org/10.36487/ACG_repo/852_8
This paper, which covers some personal experiences, provides a timely reminder that the loss of crucial
information, collectively referred to as ‘institutional memory’, in respect of the political and administrative
arrangements with high significance on the Far West Rand, can have serious consequences for mine closure.
The content brings together three parties, of whom two represent opposite sides of a water ‘war’ — a farmer
and a consultant — with a moderating and impartial third party from abroad. Since the advent of mining on
the Far West Rand during the 1930s, several parallel but interrelated events have unfolded, impacting upon
each other and left a legacy that changed the socio-economic tenure not only of the area, but also in settings
as remote as parliament and global stock exchanges. Each major event led to a host of studies that have
made the Far West Rand one of the best studied mining areas in the world. In practice the ad hoc studies
produced many unrelated data segments that are hosted in a number of insecure archives. Furthermore
along the timeline, there is a range of undertakings and liability partnerships that include government pre-
set closure conditions, some of which have conveniently been forgotten. The main author, a 50+ year
‘participant’ in the events on the Far West Rand, recounts his experience with Dolomitic groundwater and
selected parallel developments that impacted on the area in a non-technical overview that illustrates the
wide scope and volume of work done over more than 100 years in the Wonderfontein catchment. Some of the
lessons that can be learned from this unique experience, using the pre-mining groundwater studies as a
baseline and taking into account the advent of mining, resultant dewatering and the unforeseen scale of
ground movement, may assist those whose task it will be to plan for mine closure. Closure of the mines of the
Far West Rand is a given. Rehabilitation is thus not an option that can avoid the consequences of a reversal
of the dewatering policy when the pumps stop. The possibility of reactivating the ground movement and the
associated threat of pollution cannot be discounted if the process is not managed. It can, therefore, be
argued that the experience which is on record could repeat itself in reverse. The history of the area presents
a strong argument, in the case of the Far West Rand, to take cognizance of the potential pitfalls and why
what is left of the institutional memory should be secured for posterity.
Blyvooruitzicht Mine (1938) Contract with Oberholzer Irrigation Board.
Botha, S. (1969) Permit to East and West Driefontein to dewater the Bank compartment.
Bond, W.R. (1958) Letter to the Director of Water Affairs. Personal Archive.
Busschau, W.J. (1950) The Measure of Gold. Central News Agency Ltd. South Africa, 164 p.
Cable, W.H. (1957) Department of Mines submission to the Interdepartmental Committee.
Campbell Pitt, L.T. (1964) Memo for Mr. C. B. Anderson.
Claassens, G.C.H. (1986) Permit Issues to Western Areas Gold Mine, 21/04/1986.
Cousens, R.R.M and Garret, W.S. (1969) The flooding of the West Driefontein Mine. Proceedings 9th Com Mining and
Metallurgical Congress, London, England.
Dart, R.A. (1953) Africa’s Place in the Human Story. South African Broadcasting Corporation 32 p.
Department of Water Affairs Permits (1956 et sequi).
De Swart, S.J. (1956) Memorandum to the Secretary for Water Affairs from the Department of Agriculture.
De Wet, C. (1967) Press Release by the Minister of Mines. Personal Archive
Director of Water Affairs (1957) Disposal of water pumped from the shafts of the Venterspost, West Driefontein and
Blyvooruitzicht Gold Mines.
Engelbrecht, C.J. (1986) The West Wits Line. In E.S.A. Antrobus (1969) Witwatersrand Gold – 100 Years. Geological
Society of South Africa, pp. 199–223.
Engels, J.R. (1964) Minutes of First Meeting of the Technical Committee on Sink-holes and Subsidences on the Far
Enslin, J.F., Kent, L.E., Havemann, A.R., Neethling, C.J., Cable, W.H., Jordaan, J.M. and Kriel, J.P. (1958) Beskikking
oor water wat uit die skagte van goudmyne in die Verre Wes-Rand gepomp word.
Keynote and Plenary Sessions
Enslin, J.F. (1964) Hydrological Memoir on Ground-water supplies in the Republic of South Africa and their
development, use and control. Division of Hydrological Research, Government Printer 42 p.
Enslin, J.F. (1971) Confidential Memorandum to the Minister of Mines regarding dewatering and the formation of
sinkholes in the Oberholzer, Venterspost and Bank compartments. Personal Archive.
Fisher, R.M (1964a) Minutes of the second Joint Committee.
Fisher, R.M. (1964b) Draft Constitution of the Far West Rand Dolomitic Water Association.
Fleischer, J.N.E. (1981) The geohydrology of the dolomite aquifers of the Malmani sub-group in the South-Western
Transvaal, Republic of South Africa.
Funke, J.W. (1990) The water requirements and pollution potential of South African gold and uranium mines. WEC
Publication, KV 9/90.
FWRDWA (1964) Constitution of the Far West Rand Dolomitic Association.
FWRDWA (1964 et sequi) Minutes of Meetings.
Gibbs, T.L. (1964) Report of the Joint Committee appointed by agreement on the 2 December.
Haak, J.F.W. (1964) Letter to the President of the Gold Producers’ Committee.
Hunter, W. and Duff, M.B. (1904) Report on the Transvaal-Rand Water Supply. Middleton, Hunter and Duff,
Westminster, London S.W. 47 p.
Irving, C.J. (1964) Comment on the dewatering of the Oberholzer Dolomitic Compartment.
Jordaan, J.M., Enslin, J.F., Kriel, J.P., Havemann, A.R., Kent, L.E. and Cable, W.H. (1960) Final Report of the
Interdepartmental Committee on Dolomitic Mine Water: Far West Rand.
Jordaan, J.M. (1963) Confidential Minutes of discussions between the Honourable P. M. K. le Roux, Minister of Water
Affairs and the Honourable Dr. N. Diedericks, Minister of Economic Affairs on the one hand and
Representatives of the Gold Mining Industry on the other, held in Pretoria on 2 December.
Jordaan, J.M. (1967) Minutes of Meeting with the Deputy Minister of Water Affairs.
Lednor, M. (1986) The West Rand Goldfield. In E.S.A. Antrobus (1969), Witwatersrand Gold – 100 Years. Geological
Society of South Africa, pp. 49–109.
Le Roux, P.M.K. (1964) Permit Issued to West Driefontein Gold Mine to dewater the Oberholzer Compartment.
Milne, A.T. (1964) Report on meeting of the Gold Producers’ Committee with Representatives of Government.
Minutes (1963) Conference on Dolomitic Mine Water. Personal Archive.
Mudd, J.B. (1964) Letter to the Chairman, Western Deep Levels Limited. 19 October.
Myburgh, J.J. (1970) Supreme Court of South Africa (TPD) Court Order.
Oberholzer Irrigation Board (1948 et sequi) Various Minutes.
Potgieter, J.R. (1968) Decision of Minister of Water Affairs, Instruction to Secretary of Water Affairs, 13/12/1968.
Ramsden, H.T. (1985) The Status, Powers and Duties of the Rand Water Board. PhD Thesis, University of the
Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa.
Rand Water Arbitration Proceedings (1904)
Retief, G. and Stoch, E.J. (1967) Memorandum presented to the Deputy Minister of Water Affairs.
SCTC (1964) Minutes of the Second meeting of the SCTC.
Secretary of Mines (1964) Letter to Director of Geological Survey.
Secretary of Mines (1964) Memorandum to Cabinet, 30 November.
Stallebrass, J.L. (1963) Letter to Dr. G. J. Stander.
Stander, G.J. (1964) Kommentaar oor die Finale Verslag van die Tussen-Departementele Komitee.
Swart, C.J.U., Stoch, E.J., van Jaarsveld, C.F. and Brink, A.B.A. (2003) The Lower Wonderfontein Spruit – an exposé.
Environmental Geology 43, pp. 635–653.
Thomas, B. (1968) Report on an Underground Inspection at West Driefontein.
Tindall, B.T. (1968) Note for the Record: Dewatering of the Bank compartment and other matters.
Tindall, B.T. (1964) Letter to the Secretary of Water Affairs.
Truter, F.C. (1963) Report of the Joint Committee on Dewatering of Mines, Far West Rand.
Van der Merwe Brink, C., Murray, W.A., Adelaar, T.F., van Woerkom, J., Enslin, J.F., Basson, J.K., Oosthuizen, J.F.,
Stoch, E.J., Henzen, M.R. and de Beer, H.J. (1971) Finale Verslag oor Vermoedelike skade deur mynwaters aan
diere en gewasse in the Oberholzer-besproeiingsgebied.
Werdmüller, V.W. (1986) The Central Rand. In Witwatersrand Gold – 100 Years E. S. A. Antrobus, Geological Society
of South Africa, pp. 7–47.
Wessels, J.W., Strange, W.L., Rissik, J., Neser, J.A., Armstrong, B.H.O. and Grobler, E.R. (1905) Interim Report of the
Inter-Colonial Irrigation Commission. Government Printer, Pretoria.
Winde, F., Erasmus, E. and Stoch, E.J. (2005) Report on the Western and Far Western Basins; CGS. Unpublished.
Wolmarans, F.J. (1985) Ontwatering van die Dolomiet gebied aan die Verre Wes-Rand: Gebeure in perspektief, 255 p.